A friend of mine got her very first account back fairly recently. She has been playing 9 years according to her main.
I think it just depends, like Dimitri said, if they have started to purge the account, then you won't get it back.
Good luck to starting again. Enjoy neo!
It can be great fun
Copyright © 2018, © 1999 – 2018 Neopets, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Used with permission. All other © 2007 – 2018 NeoMallers